Қайталанымдылық · Орташа
Template 16: Decision, deviation and qualitative analysis log
Use this record to preserve why a decision was made and what information was available at the time. It supports transparent reporting and helps distinguish planned decisions from exploration.
3 мин оқу · 2026 ж. 26 қаз.
Бұл бет әлі аударылмаған, сондықтан ағылшын нұсқасын оқып отырсыз.
Негізгі тұжырымдар
- Adapt the prompts to the actual study.
- Complete every statement from verified records.
- Follow the target journal and institutional requirements.
Мазмұны
Use this record to preserve why a decision was made and what information was available at the time. It supports transparent reporting and helps distinguish planned decisions from exploration.
Use this record to preserve why a decision was made and what information was available at the time. It supports transparent reporting and helps distinguish planned decisions from exploration.
General decision record
Date and responsible person: [Details]
Decision: [Specific choice]
Original plan: [Protocol version and relevant text]
Reason for change: [New information, practical constraint, error correction or scientific rationale]
Information already examined: [Whether group labels, outcomes or preliminary results were known]
Alternatives considered: [Options and reasons]
Effect on the analysis or interpretation: [Consequences]
Required approvals or notifications: [Actual process and status]
Files or manuscript sections affected: [Locations]
Exclusion or correction record
Unit identifier: [Nonidentifying code]
Issue and evidence: [Documented error or quality failure]
Rule applied: [Prespecified criterion or transparent later decision]
Action: [Retain, correct, exclude or analyse separately]
Original and revised values, if applicable: [Values]
Sensitivity check: [Result of a justified alternative]
Qualitative analytic memo
Material considered: [Interview, observation or document identifiers]
Initial interpretation: [Claim and supporting material]
Code or theme development: [How the interpretation evolved]
Contradictory or alternative material: [Evidence that complicates the claim]
Researcher position: [Relevant assumptions or relationships]
Analytic discussion: [Contributors and issues considered]
Current conclusion and limits: [Bounded interpretation]
Quotation and identity check: [Source verification and confidentiality review]
Sensitivity summary
| Decision tested | Primary choice | Plausible alternative | Result of comparison | Effect on conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [Decision] | [Choice] | [Alternative] | [Verified result] | [Interpretation] |
Retain the record even when a change seems minor at the time. Do not rewrite the chronology to make an exploratory decision appear prespecified.
Tutorial: preserve a decision's chronology and consequence
Read Article 18 and Article 28. Write a log entry when the decision occurs, not only while drafting the final paper. Record what information was visible and which options were considered. This allows readers to distinguish a planned rule from a response to the observed findings.
Hypothetical quantitative entry: A sensor reading appears impossible. The investigator checks the original instrument export, confirms a transcription error, preserves the original file and corrects the working dataset. The log records the evidence and the affected output. If the original reading cannot be verified, the entry records uncertainty rather than silently replacing it with a plausible value.
Hypothetical qualitative entry: An early interpretation suggests that students avoid asking for help because of embarrassment. A later account describes a different reason: previous requests were unanswered. The memo records how the interpretation changes and whether the emerging theme needs a broader explanation. It does not treat the later account as a statistical outlier to remove.
Completion check: Can another reader understand both the decision and its effect on the claim? State whether the final conclusion changes under a justified alternative. Retain decisions that did not alter the result; a record consisting only of successful choices gives an incomplete account of the work.