Мазмұнға өту

Жазу · Орташа

Template 8: Narrative review manuscript

Use this for a focused scholarly synthesis. Adapt headings to the topic and journal. Do not describe the review as systematic unless its actual methods justify that description.

4 мин оқу · 2026 ж. 26 қаз.

Бұл бет әлі аударылмаған, сондықтан ағылшын нұсқасын оқып отырсыз.

Негізгі тұжырымдар

  • Adapt the prompts to the actual study.
  • Complete every statement from verified records.
  • Follow the target journal and institutional requirements.
Мазмұны

Use this for a focused scholarly synthesis. Adapt headings to the topic and journal. Do not describe the review as systematic unless its actual methods justify that description.

Use this for a focused scholarly synthesis. Adapt headings to the topic and journal. Do not describe the review as systematic unless its actual methods justify that description.

Title and author information

Title: [Topic and analytical focus]: a narrative review

Authors, affiliations and correspondence: [Verified information]

Keywords: [Concepts, systems and methods relevant to discovery]

Abstract

Purpose: [The question or conceptual problem addressed.]

Scope and approach: [Main boundaries and how the literature was located and selected.]

Synthesis: [The most important relationships, disagreements or methodological insights.]

Conclusion: [Defensible interpretation and the most useful next question.]

Follow journal instructions for a structured or unstructured abstract. Do not claim quantitative pooled effects that were not calculated through an appropriate synthesis.

Introduction

[Explain the problem and intended audience. Establish the need for this synthesis using the existing evidence. Define important terms and distinguish the review’s scope from related topics.]

“This review examines [question] in [defined context]. We focus on [included concepts or systems] and consider [important boundary]. Our aim is to [compare, explain, integrate or evaluate].”

Literature identification and scope

[Describe databases or sources, search dates, concepts or queries, relevant restrictions and additional discovery methods. Explain how studies were selected and what limitations the approach creates.]

“Sources were selected for [explicit relevance criteria]. The search was intended to [purpose]. It was not designed to establish [an unsupported comprehensiveness claim].”

Use the final sentence only if it accurately describes the method. A transparent explanation is more useful than a label chosen to sound rigorous.

Theme 1: [A scientific question or mechanism]

[State the main issue. Compare the relevant evidence across studies. Discuss design and measurement differences. End with what this body of evidence supports and leaves uncertain.]

Theme 2: [A competing explanation or methodological distinction]

[Present credible alternative interpretations. Explain which observations favour each and what evidence could discriminate among them.]

Theme 3: [A boundary, application or unresolved issue]

[Connect the evidence to a specific context while preserving limits. Avoid extending conclusions to populations or systems that were not represented.]

Evidence comparison table

Study Design and system Main measurement Finding and uncertainty Limitation relevant to synthesis
[Verified citation] [Details] [Definition] [Result] [Specific issue]

Integrative discussion

[Explain how the themes fit together. Distinguish established patterns, plausible interpretations and unresolved questions. Discuss limitations of the literature and of your search or selection process.]

Proposed conceptual illustration: [Describe the relationships to show. Mark hypothetical links and cite the underlying evidence.]

Future research

[Identify specific designs, measurements, populations or comparisons needed to resolve the main uncertainty. Explain why each proposed study would be informative.]

Conclusion

[State the review’s principal contribution without suggesting that every uncertainty has been resolved.]

Declarations and references

[Use Template 12 for verified declarations and Template 3 to check source support. Confirm permissions for reused or adapted material.]

Tutorial: write one synthesis paragraph before expanding the outline

Read Article 26. Select a small group of relevant papers and ask one analytical question of all of them. Compare their populations or systems, measurements, study designs and limitations. Use the answers to form a provisional theme. A theme is a relationship or explanation that helps the reader understand the evidence; a topic label alone is not yet a synthesis.

Hypothetical paragraph plan: A review of low cost air sensors could group studies by whether calibration was assessed under laboratory reference conditions or changing outdoor conditions. The first sentence states the analytical distinction. The middle sentences compare the evidence and explain why humidity, calibration transfer or location could matter. The last sentence states what remains unresolved. Actual claims about sensor performance would require verified studies and measurements; this plan supplies a structure, not those empirical findings.

Source check: Record which source supports each clause. If a review points you to a primary experiment, read the primary report before describing its methods or numerical results as directly verified. When access is unavailable, be transparent about reliance on the secondary account.

Completion check: Remove the author names temporarily from one section. Does the section still have a logical argument, or does it become an unrelated list of findings? Revise around comparisons and uncertainty until the reasoning is clear. Restore precise citations before sharing the draft.