Мазмұнға өту

Жазу · Орташа

Template 9: Systematic review protocol and manuscript framework

This worksheet helps organise a review. It is not an official PRISMA checklist and does not replace a methodological handbook, appropriate training or the relevant reporting extension.

4 мин оқу · 2026 ж. 26 қаз.

Бұл бет әлі аударылмаған, сондықтан ағылшын нұсқасын оқып отырсыз.

Негізгі тұжырымдар

  • Adapt the prompts to the actual study.
  • Complete every statement from verified records.
  • Follow the target journal and institutional requirements.
Мазмұны

This worksheet helps organise a review. It is not an official PRISMA checklist and does not replace a methodological handbook, appropriate training or the relevant reporting extension.

This worksheet helps organise a review. It is not an official PRISMA checklist and does not replace a methodological handbook, appropriate training or the relevant reporting extension.

Protocol

Review type and rationale: [Systematic, scoping or another defined type; why it matches the question]

Question: [Population or system, intervention or exposure, comparator, outcomes and relevant context]

Eligibility: [Designs, settings, populations, outcomes, time periods and publication types]

Restrictions: [Language, dates or other restrictions with rationale]

Information sources: [Databases, registries, citation searches and other sources]

Search strategy: [Complete draft for each source, with fields and syntax checked]

Search support: [Librarian or other methodological input actually obtained]

Record management: [Exports, deduplication and linkage of reports from the same study]

Screening: [Reviewers, independence, decision rules and disagreements]

Extraction: [Fields, piloting, checking and handling of unclear reports]

Risk of bias: [Appropriate tool by design, process and use in interpretation]

Synthesis: [Grouping logic, effect measures, dependence, statistical model if applicable and alternatives when pooling is unsuitable]

Heterogeneity and missing evidence: [Assessment and interpretation plan]

Confidence in the evidence: [Appropriate approach and scope]

Registration or archive: [Actual location and status]

Amendments: [Dated changes with reasons]

Extraction record for each study

Study identifier and linked reports: [Identifiers]

Design, setting and recruitment: [Details]

Participants or units: [Sample sizes, characteristics and losses]

Intervention or exposure and comparator: [Definitions]

Outcome and time point: [Exact measurement]

Numerical data: [Values needed to reconstruct the effect and its uncertainty]

Analysis and adjustment: [Method and relevant covariates]

Bias assessment: [Judgments with supporting report locations]

Missing or unclear information: [Issue and contact or handling decision]

Extractor and verifier: [Who checked which fields]

Manuscript structure

Title and abstract: Identify the review type and report the question, methods, included evidence, main findings and limitations.

Introduction: Explain the question and why the review is needed.

Methods: Report the protocol, eligibility, sources, complete searches, selection, extraction, assessments and synthesis procedures actually used.

Results: Present the selection flow, included study characteristics, risk of bias, findings by outcome and synthesis with uncertainty. Separate study counts from report counts.

Discussion: Interpret the body of evidence, its limitations and the review’s limitations. Explain implications proportionately.

Declarations and supporting information: Provide funding, interests, contributions, protocol, full strategies, extraction definitions, exclusion reasons and data or code access where appropriate.

Flow reconciliation

Records identified: [Count]

Removed before screening: [Duplicates and other reasons]

Records screened and excluded: [Counts]

Reports sought and unavailable: [Counts]

Reports assessed and excluded: [Counts with reasons]

Reports included: [Count]

Distinct studies represented: [Count]

Reconcile every transition and use the relevant official flow template for the final report. PRISMA resources are linked in the source register. S06 S38

Tutorial: pilot the review before committing to the whole search

Read Article 27. Test the eligibility rules on a small set of deliberately varied records. Include an obviously relevant report, an obviously irrelevant one and an ambiguous one. Record how reviewers apply each criterion and revise unclear definitions before the main screening. Preserve dated changes and state whether any extracted findings were already known.

Hypothetical engineering review decision: A review comparing predictive maintenance algorithms must define whether it includes simulated faults, physical equipment, public benchmark datasets or all three. If the same benchmark appears in several reports, record the shared dataset; those papers do not automatically represent independent real world replications. Define the performance metric and evaluation setting before comparing results.

Add a synthesis decision record: State which studies can be compared, which effect measure or outcome representation will be used, how repeated estimates from a study will be handled, and what will happen when compatible numerical data are unavailable. A systematic review can use a structured synthesis without a pooled estimate. Describe the evidence and its limitations rather than counting how many papers crossed a p value threshold.

Completion check: Reconcile the record, report and study counts. Reconstruct one extracted estimate from its reported inputs where feasible. Keep the official reporting checklist separate from your assessment of study bias; completeness of reporting and credibility of the design answer different questions.

Sources

S06: PRISMA. PRISMA 2020 resources

S38: PRISMA. Scoping review extension