Перейти к содержанию

Публикация · Начальный

Template 14: Response to editors and reviewers

Keep a complete response to every comment. Distinguish the reviewer’s words from your response and identify the revised manuscript version.

3 мин чтения · 26 окт. 2026 г.

Эта страница ещё не переведена, поэтому вы читаете английскую версию.

Главное

  • Adapt the prompts to the actual study.
  • Complete every statement from verified records.
  • Follow the target journal and institutional requirements.
Содержание

Keep a complete response to every comment. Distinguish the reviewer’s words from your response and identify the revised manuscript version.

Keep a complete response to every comment. Distinguish the reviewer’s words from your response and identify the revised manuscript version.

Opening

Dear [Editor],

Thank you for the assessment of “[Manuscript title]”, reference [actual manuscript identifier]. We have revised the manuscript and respond to each comment below. The main changes are [brief description of substantive changes]. Locations refer to [clean or marked version and date].

Comment record

Editor or reviewer: [Identifier]

Comment number: [Number]

Comment: [Accurate quotation or full requested point]

Response: [Direct answer and scientific reasoning]

Change made: [What changed, including any analysis and its effect on interpretation]

Location: [Section, figure, table or page information matching the submitted version]

Revised wording, where useful: [Exact new wording]

Repeat this record for every comment, including minor points.

Example: accepting a correction

“We agree that the original caption did not distinguish independent layouts from repeated runs. We have revised the Methods and figure legend to define the layout as the analysis unit and to describe aggregation within each layout. [Explain whether recalculation changed any result, using actual facts.]”

Example: justified disagreement

“We understand the concern about [issue]. We retained [decision] because [methodological reason and supporting evidence]. To make the limitation explicit, we added [specific explanation] to [location]. [Include a sensitivity analysis if appropriate and actually performed.]”

Example: request outside the available evidence

“The requested experiment would address [question], but the present study does not contain those observations. We have narrowed the claim from [original claim] to [supported claim] and identified the experiment as a future test.”

Do not describe a request as impossible merely because it is inconvenient. Explain the scientific scope honestly and follow the editor’s requirements.

Final audit

Check that every claimed change exists in the manuscript, that numerical changes propagate to all sections and that all authors approve the revision. Keep the tone professional even when comments are mistaken. An unanswered comment is easier to detect than a complicated explanation of why it was skipped.

Tutorial: make each response independently checkable

Read Article 30. Copy the reviewer's comment accurately, then answer its central concern. State what changed, where it changed and why the revision resolves the issue. Update page or line references after the revised manuscript is final, since editing can move the quoted passage.

Hypothetical response: “Thank you for asking how repeated measurements were handled. We have clarified that observations were grouped by independently assembled device and have revised the analysis description accordingly. The Methods now identifies the device identifier and the treatment of measurements within devices. We also revised the legend so its sample size refers to devices.” Only use such wording if the analysis and manuscript were actually checked and revised.

When you disagree: Explain the scientific reason and offer a useful clarification where possible. For example, if a requested analysis would answer a different question, state that difference and explain whether it belongs in a clearly labelled exploratory section. Do not claim that an unavailable experiment was performed.

Completion check: Compare the response letter with the submitted revision. Every promised change should be present; every new result should have a documented method; and every remaining limitation should be reflected consistently in the Abstract, Discussion and Conclusion.