Публикация · Начальный
Template 15: Submission and proof audit
For each item, record **checked**, **not applicable with reason**, or **needs action**. Identify the evidence inspected and the person responsible. A checked box without inspection is not a verification.
4 мин чтения · 26 окт. 2026 г.
Эта страница ещё не переведена, поэтому вы читаете английскую версию.
Главное
- Adapt the prompts to the actual study.
- Complete every statement from verified records.
- Follow the target journal and institutional requirements.
Содержание
For each item, record checked, not applicable with reason, or needs action. Identify the evidence inspected and the person responsible. A checked box without inspection is not a verification.
For each item, record checked, not applicable with reason, or needs action. Identify the evidence inspected and the person responsible. A checked box without inspection is not a verification.
Scientific argument
- The title, aim, design and conclusion address the same question.
- The primary outcome and independent unit are explicit.
- Claims about causation, generalisation and practical importance match the evidence.
- Planned outcomes, relevant negative findings and exploratory analyses are reported transparently.
- Limitations explain their effect on interpretation.
Methods and analysis
- Sampling, controls, allocation, masking and exclusions are described as actually performed.
- The sample size rationale and stopping rule are recorded.
- Pairing, repeated observations and clusters are handled appropriately.
- Missing data and unusual values have documented handling decisions.
- Models, assumptions, diagnostics, uncertainty and multiple comparison methods are stated.
- The main calculations can be reproduced from the documented inputs.
Figures, tables and text
- Values, signs, units, denominators and precision match across the abstract, text, figures and tables.
- Every figure defines observations, summaries, uncertainty and sample sizes.
- Axes, legends, scale bars and image processing are clear.
- Scientific images preserve the original evidence and disclose relevant processing.
- Tables are readable text with defined missing values and abbreviations.
- Alt text communicates the main information without relying on colour.
Ethics, credit and sources
- Required approvals, consent and permissions exist and are described accurately.
- All authors satisfy the journal’s criteria and approve the submitted version.
- Funding, interests, contributions, data access and AI assistance are complete and verified.
- Every factual claim has appropriate support, and cited sources have been checked.
- References match in text citations, with correct metadata and relevant versions.
- Reused material has the required licence, permission and attribution.
Journal requirements
- The article type, scope, length, format and reporting checklist match current instructions.
- Related manuscripts, preprints and overlap are disclosed as required.
- Every template placeholder and instructional note has been removed.
- All required files are present, readable and correctly named.
- The cover letter and submission metadata agree with the manuscript.
Proof stage
- Author names, affiliations, identifiers and correspondence are correct.
- Equations, symbols, figures, tables and references survived production accurately.
- Links and assigned identifiers lead to the intended material.
- Corrections are returned through the journal’s process and approved by the responsible authors.
Audit record: [Item; status; evidence; reviewer; date; action]
Tutorial: audit the chain from evidence to claim
Use Article 31 for revision. Perform separate passes for scientific reasoning, numerical accuracy, references and presentation. Trying to check everything while correcting grammar makes major problems easier to miss.
Evidence pass: For each central conclusion, identify the result that supports it, the analysis that produced the result and the observations that entered the analysis. Check the unit of replication, exclusions and missing data. For a review, trace the synthesis back to the extracted study evidence and appraisal judgments.
Numerical pass: Compare the Abstract, text, tables and figures. Check units, subtraction direction, sample sizes, percentages, interval bounds and rounding. A p value should not be written as zero merely because software rounded its display. Ensure that exploratory analyses and synthetic teaching values are unmistakably labelled where present.
Reference pass: Confirm that each citation exists, supports its nearby claim and matches the reference list. Follow the persistent link to check the version and any correction information. A functioning DOI is not proof that a paper's methods or conclusions are sound.
Presentation pass: Inspect the actual exported file or website preview. Check table width, figure labels, alt text, heading order and links. Remove instructional placeholders from an empirical submission. Preserve them only in worksheets clearly presented as teaching templates.