Publishing · Beginner
Choose a journal, submit responsibly and respond to review
Choose a suitable journal and handle submission, review and corrections responsibly.
13 min read · Oct 26, 2026
Key points
- Check journal fit and claims.
- Respond to every review point.
- Understand versions and persistent identifiers.
Contents
Choose a suitable journal and handle submission, review and corrections responsibly.
Publication makes a paper available for examination, discussion and reuse. It does not convert uncertain findings into certainty or remove the authors' responsibility for the work. A strong submission gives editors and reviewers a clear question, an appropriate method, a transparent account of the evidence and conclusions that stay within that evidence.
This tutorial explains the publication process for original research and review articles. It provides fictional correspondence examples for practice. Requirements vary across disciplines and venues, so check the actual destination's current instructions. This guide does not promise a particular review process, acceptance decision, fee, indexing service or DOI for YRH or any other website.
Decide who should read the paper
Choose an audience before comparing journal metrics. A paper explaining a local educational intervention may fit a different venue from a paper developing a general statistical method, even if both use similar data. A student journal may offer an appropriate audience for careful introductory work, while a specialist journal may expect deeper engagement with a narrow field.
Read the aims and scope, accepted article types and recent publications. Check whether the journal accepts the review type you have written. A narrative review, systematic review and commentary may have different requirements. For engineering and computing, conference proceedings can also be important research venues, but their deadlines, review arrangements and archival status differ. Assess the specific venue rather than treating every conference or journal as equivalent.
Ask what your paper enables readers to understand or do. That answer should appear in the title, abstract and cover letter. “This is our first publication” may explain your motivation, but it does not describe the contribution. A careful replication, transparent dataset, feasible prototype evaluation or well reasoned synthesis can have value without being described as a breakthrough.
Check the destination using independent evidence
Inspect the publisher identity, contact details, editorial board, review process, fees, licence and preservation arrangements. Verify important claims through the named organisation where possible. For example, a claim of indexing should be checked in the index itself using the journal's exact title and identifier. A logo copied onto a website is not independent verification.
Think. Check. Submit. provides a structured journal assessment resource covering these issues, including clear fees, identifiable publishers, review arrangements and discoverability. It encourages assessment of the full publication context rather than trust based on a flattering invitation. S25
Avoid deciding from one signal alone. A fee does not establish that a journal is unreliable, and absence of a fee does not prove quality. A new journal may have limited indexing without being deceptive. However, guaranteed acceptance, unclear ownership or inconsistent editorial claims require clarification before submission. Discuss an unfamiliar destination with a librarian, supervisor or experienced researcher who can evaluate the field's norms.
Create a short comparison record for your own decision: audience fit, article type, review process, expected costs, rights, practical requirements and verified indexing or archiving. Do not let a prestige measure replace the question of whether the paper and journal fit each other.
Prepare one internally consistent submission
Read the author instructions immediately before preparing files. Check the required structure, word limits, abstract format, figure specifications, reporting checklists, anonymisation and supplementary material. Verify the manuscript title and author information in both the document and submission form. An inconsistency between these versions can survive into publication metadata.
Before submission, confirm that authors have reviewed the final version, affiliations are accurate, contributions and conflicts are disclosed, and related work is identified. ICMJE's submission guidance describes cover letters or forms containing information about related reports, conflicts and author approval in medical publishing. Treat it as a relevant example of accountability while following the actual venue's rules in your discipline. S40
Use a reproducible final check. Compare every abstract number with the Results, every table with the analysis output and every figure legend with the plotted data. Check that sample sizes refer to the right units. For reviews, reconcile selection counts and verify that cited studies match the extraction record. Remove placeholder names, invented identifiers and comments intended only for the drafting team.
A blinded manuscript may require removing identifying details from the main file while supplying them in a separate title page. Do not remove essential methodological information permanently; follow the submission process for supplying it appropriately. Review metadata and document properties if the journal requests anonymisation.
Write a useful cover letter
A cover letter explains what you are submitting, why it fits and what the editor needs to know. It should not repeat the whole abstract. Identify the article type, central contribution and relevant context, then include the declarations requested by the journal. Avoid unsupported claims of being the first or best.
Fictional cover letter excerpt: “We submit a narrative review examining how differences in outcome measurement affect comparisons of peer feedback studies in university writing courses. The review organises the literature around measurement, implementation and interpretation, and identifies specific comparisons needed to resolve apparent disagreements. We believe it fits the journal's interest in research methods for education. The manuscript does not present new participant data or claim an exhaustive systematic search.”
This excerpt gives the editor a clear article type, question and boundary. In an actual submission, add the real title and requested declarations, and use a journal fit statement supported by its published scope. Do not write that every author approved the paper until that approval has occurred. Use Template 13 as a starting worksheet rather than a text to send with placeholders intact.
Handle overlap, preprints and versions transparently
Check the venue's rules on exclusive submission before sending the manuscript elsewhere. Many journals prohibit simultaneous submission of substantially the same paper. Related conference reports, preprints, theses and prior manuscripts may require disclosure. The correct response to overlap is an accurate account of what is shared and what is new, not cosmetic rewriting to hide the relationship.
A preprint is a publicly available manuscript version whose review status must be described accurately. It can make work available before journal publication, but it is not automatically the final version. Check journal policy, rights and applicable institutional requirements before posting. ICMJE's guidance on overlapping publication distinguishes several forms of prior dissemination and discusses preprints; its rules apply within its stated publishing context rather than universally to every field. S209
Keep a version record with dates and filenames. A submitted manuscript, revised manuscript, accepted manuscript and publisher version can differ. When citing or sharing, identify the appropriate version and update links when a final version appears. If a review relies on a preprint, check whether a revised or published version changes the claim you cite.
Interpret the editorial decision before editing
An editor may decline a manuscript without external review because of scope, methods, presentation, priorities or capacity. A decision after external review may request changes, reject the paper or accept it. Terms such as major revision and minor revision are venue specific; neither guarantees a particular outcome until the editor decides.
Read the decision letter as a whole. Separate concerns about the research question, evidence and analysis from presentation issues. A missing comparator may affect the main conclusion; an undefined abbreviation may be corrected directly. Addressing the most consequential issues first prevents spending hours polishing sentences that a methodological change will replace.
Create a response matrix with the reviewer comment, its underlying concern, your action, the evidence supporting that action and the manuscript location. If comments conflict, identify the conflict and explain your reasoned choice to the editor. Do not assume that every request must be followed literally, but do answer every substantive concern.
Respond with evidence and visible changes
A good response acknowledges the issue, states the action and shows where the manuscript changed. Avoid vague replies such as “Done” or “The reviewer misunderstood”. If the original writing allowed a reasonable misunderstanding, improving it is useful even when the analysis was correct.
Fictional comment: “The manuscript reports n = 120, but the experiment appears to involve twelve layouts with ten repeated runs each. Please explain the independent unit.”
Developed fictional response: “We agree that the original Methods did not distinguish layouts from repeated runs. We now state that the study includes twelve layouts, each evaluated in ten runs per controller. The primary comparison uses one summary per layout and preserves pairing between controllers. We revised the Methods, Table 1 note and Figure 2 legend to report twelve independent layout summaries and to describe the repeated runs separately. We also checked that the abstract uses the same unit.”
This response works only if it describes the actual design and analysis. If the original analysis treated all 120 runs as independent when that was unjustified, a wording change is not enough. Reanalyse appropriately, report how the estimates and intervals changed, and revise the conclusion if necessary. A response letter must not conceal a statistical correction as a minor clarification.
Explain disagreement respectfully
You may disagree with a request when it is unsuitable, unsupported or outside the question. Explain the scientific reason, make any useful clarification and identify the remaining limit. Declining an experiment without narrowing an overextended claim is rarely persuasive.
Fictional comment: “The review should combine all reported outcomes into a single effect size.”
Developed fictional response: “We agree that a concise quantitative summary would be useful if the outcomes addressed a comparable construct. In this review, the included measures assess writing quality, course grades and reported confidence, which do not define a single outcome. Pooling them would obscure that distinction. We have added a paragraph explaining the decision and expanded the synthesis table to show each outcome definition, estimate and interpretive limitation. The conclusion now explicitly states that the review does not estimate an overall effect across these outcomes.”
The response addresses the underlying wish for a clearer synthesis while defending a justified methodological boundary. Cite appropriate methodological guidance when needed. Do not use citations as decoration or appeal to authority without explaining the problem.
Fictional comment: “Please validate the prototype in outdoor conditions.”
Possible response: “Outdoor validation would address an important boundary of the present study. We cannot add that evaluation within the current project. We have therefore restricted the title, abstract and conclusion to the indoor conditions tested and added a specific limitation describing the environmental factors that remain unevaluated.”
An editor may still decide that the additional work is necessary. A respectful, transparent response supports an informed decision; it does not guarantee acceptance.
Keep review material and author decisions organised
Retain the original decision letter, a clean revised manuscript, a version showing changes when requested, and the response document. Use stable comment numbers and manuscript locations. If pagination changes during revision, update all response references before uploading. A reviewer should not need to search for the promised change.
Ensure all authors understand substantial new analyses and conclusions. Do not add an analysis solely to obtain a favourable p value. Label new exploratory analyses, explain their rationale and disclose that they arose during review. If a reviewer requests inappropriate citations or raises an issue that requires editorial judgement, address it factually through the journal's process.
Review comments may be confidential under the venue's arrangements. Check applicable policies before posting them publicly or uploading unpublished manuscripts and comments to an external service. Do not assume that access to a document gives permission for every form of redistribution.
Understand access, licences and identifiers
Open access concerns access and reuse arrangements. It does not mean that every image, dataset or passage can be reused without conditions. Read the licence attached to the specific item. Creative Commons licences differ in conditions relating to attribution, adaptation and commercial use; third party material may have separate rights. S515
A DOI is a persistent digital identifier linked to a maintained destination and metadata. It helps identify and locate an output. It does not certify that the item was peer reviewed, that its findings are correct or that it is indexed in a particular database. Crossref registers identifiers for several research output types and explicitly distinguishes an identifier from a quality mark. S26 S45
Never invent a DOI for a manuscript or predict that one will be assigned without a confirmed service and policy. Similarly, a journal's indexing and preservation claims should be described using verified information, not inferred from the existence of a DOI or a professional looking website.
Continue checking after acceptance
Proofs are the formatted publication version prepared for author checking. Inspect author names, affiliations, equations, units, tables, figure order, legends, citations, links and supplementary files. Check special characters and minus signs carefully. A typesetting error can reverse an interpretation even when the accepted manuscript was correct.
If you discover a material error after publication, contact the editor promptly with the affected text or result, the evidence and the likely impact. A correction may address an error without invalidating the whole paper; a retraction or other notice may be needed when findings are unreliable or other serious issues apply. The journal determines the appropriate process. ICMJE's guidance distinguishes correcting factual errors from ordinary scientific disagreement and calls for a transparent version record. S36
Do not silently replace a public result while leaving readers unaware that the conclusion changed. Preserve the relationship between versions and explain the correction clearly. Responsibility for a paper continues after its acceptance email.
Practice and model answer
Task: A reviewer requests a new subgroup analysis. You perform it after seeing the main results and obtain p = 0.04. Draft an honest response and decide what the paper should say.
Model answer: “At the reviewer's suggestion, we added an exploratory subgroup analysis. We now describe its rationale, model, effect estimate and uncertainty, and identify it as introduced during revision. Because it was not part of the original analysis plan and additional comparisons were examined, we interpret it cautiously and do not use it to replace the primary conclusion.”
The paper should also address the relevant multiplicity and whether the subgroup contrast was directly tested. Do not describe a significant result in one subgroup and a nonsignificant result in another as proof that the groups differ. Apply Article 16 to the comparison family and Article 17 to the model interpretation.
Use Template 14 for the response record and Template 15 before submission and proof approval. Each check should point to evidence you actually inspected.