Version 1.0.6
Editorial and Publication Ethics Policy
In force since November 18, 2026
YRH Journal publishes original research by school students (with a parent's consent), undergraduates and early-stage PhD students. This policy says what we publish, how decisions are made, what we expect of authors, and what happens when something goes wrong. It follows the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) core practices and forms part of the Terms of Use for every author.
1. Scope and article types
We publish Research Articles (experimental, computational or data-analysis work) and Review Articles in any scientific field, written in English (Russian and Kazakh abstracts are welcome; full papers in those languages will be accepted when the setting that enables them is switched on). Papers are tagged "High school research", "Undergraduate research" or "PhD research" so that readers judge them at the right level. A paper must not be under consideration elsewhere and must not have been published before (a preprint or a school science-fair poster is not prior publication; say so in the cover declarations).
2. How a paper is handled
- Submission. You submit through the Platform, either as a PDF or in the structured editor. Every submission receives an identifier such as YRH-2026-0001 and a visible status timeline. Anyone with an account may submit (school and university students, PhD students, researchers, teachers and professors) without confirming a school or university. An author under 18 submits once the parent has confirmed the account; that one approval covers every later submission, and the parent is notified of each. Before the parent confirms, a minor cannot start a paper, upload a file or be added as an author.
- Screening. An editor checks scope, completeness, ethics declarations and obvious plagiarism, normally within 7 days.
- Peer review. The editors invite one or more reviewers for a paper that passes screening: teachers, professors, and PhD students and researchers with at least one published paper. An invited reviewer does not need to confirm their school or university, and minors and parents never review. Reviewers advise; the editors decide. Reviewers stay anonymous to authors: authors read the reviews without the reviewer's name. Reviewers declare conflicts of interest and never review a paper they authored, supervised or submitted. Reviews use a short rubric (question, methods, statistics and evidence, whether the results support the conclusions, originality, clarity, ethics), scored 1 to 5, and are written to teach, not only to judge. We aim to have every accepted paper reviewed by at least one reviewer; the editors may decide without a review, for example when they reject a paper at screening.
- Decision. A person, never software, decides: accept, request a minor or major revision, or reject, with a letter explaining why. Target: a decision within 6 weeks of submission.
- Revision. A revision is a new version with a response to the reviewers; earlier versions stay readable to editors. Authors may withdraw at any time before a decision, free of charge.
- Production and publication. Accepted papers are typeset, each author accepts the Author Agreement (an author aged 14 to 17 accepts it themselves, and the parent's consent is needed to publish their name), and the paper appears in the next edition under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence with full citation metadata. Authors may add a cover image; without one, the journal shows a plain cover in the colour of the subject.
- Comments. Members who have a confirmed school or university and at least one published paper of their own may comment on published papers, as the Community Guidelines describe. A comment can be deleted by its author and by staff.
3. Authorship
Authorship follows the CRediT contributor roles. Every listed author must have made a substantial contribution, approved the final version and agreed to be accountable for it. A supervisor is a co-author only if they contributed to the work itself; otherwise they are acknowledged. Each co-author confirms their authorship by email before submission; the corresponding author answers for the paper. Changes to the author list after submission need a written explanation signed by every author.
4. Use of artificial intelligence
- What is allowed. You may use AI tools to brainstorm, and to improve grammar, language and structure.
- Say how you used them. The submission form asks about the use of AI tools: either you did not use them, or you used them as allowed and describe briefly which tools and for what. Editors see your answer, and it is published with the paper's declarations.
- What is not allowed. AI must never generate data, results, figures, images or references, or write the paper for you. A paper fully generated by AI, with no original idea of the authors, will be rejected.
- AI is never an author. The authors are responsible for every part of the paper, including text an AI tool helped to improve.
- Undisclosed AI use, or use beyond what you declared, is treated as misconduct (Section 6).
5. Research ethics
- Every study with people, including class surveys and questionnaires, needs informed consent from the participants, and a parent's consent for participants under 18. Personal data of participants must be anonymised in the paper and its supplements.
- Biomedical research seeks new knowledge about human life and health, diseases, and their diagnosis, treatment or prevention, for example work with medicines, medical devices, biological samples or medical information. It is accepted only with a positive conclusion of a competent bioethics commission (ethics committee), given before the research started. In Kazakhstan this is the Central Commission on Bioethics or a local bioethics commission certified by it (Rules for conducting biomedical research, approved by Order of the Minister of Health of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. ҚР ДСМ-310/2020 of 21 December 2020, point 5); elsewhere, an ethics committee competent under the law of the country where the research was done. The submission form asks for the committee's name and country, the number and date of its conclusion, and your confirmation that it was given before the research started; you may upload the document. A school's permission is not enough for biomedical research.
- Other studies with people (for example a survey, a questionnaire or an observation that is not biomedical) need the permission of the school or an ethics committee's approval, as appropriate for that kind of study; the form asks who gave it.
- Research on animals is accepted only through an institution with an approved ethics committee, and never when any author of the paper is under 18.
- Work with hazardous materials or dual-use potential is rejected.
6. Misconduct
Fabrication or falsification of data, image manipulation that changes what an image shows, plagiarism (including self-plagiarism and unattributed translation), a paper generated by AI with no original idea of the authors, and undisclosed AI use lead to rejection, and the supervisor or school is informed. Published papers found to involve misconduct are retracted (Section 9). We follow COPE flowcharts when investigating.
7. Conflicts of interest
Authors declare funding sources and any financial or personal relationship that could be seen to influence the work. Editors and reviewers declare conflicts and step aside from papers by students at their own institution, by relatives, or by people they supervise. The operator never handles a paper they authored or supervise.
8. Appeals and complaints
You may appeal a decision once, within 30 days, by writing to [email protected] with your reasons. The appeal is considered afresh by an editor who did not take the decision, once the journal has more than one editor; until then the editor-in-chief considers it again and may ask a reviewer for an independent opinion. Complaints about the process or about an editor's conduct go to the same address and are answered within 30 days. These 30 days apply to editorial complaints only. A complaint about a paid service (for example a fee or a refund) is a consumer complaint: we send our reasoned written reply to it within 10 calendar days, as Section 7 of the Terms of Sale says, and the 30 days never replace that.
9. Corrections, retractions and the permanent record
Published papers are never silently changed. A material error is corrected by a dated correction notice linked from the article; a paper whose findings are unreliable or whose publication breached this policy is retracted with a notice that stays online, so the record remains complete. Authors may ask for a correction at any time. A published paper remains part of the scholarly record even if the author later leaves the Platform; the author's consented byline stays, the profile link is removed.
Removal on request. A person may ask us at [email protected] to correct or remove their name or affiliation in a published paper, or to take the paper off the website (for example because of a risk to their safety or an unlawful disclosure of personal data). Staff assess each request, record their decision with its reason, and do one of these:
- Hide the paper from the website, where it is then shown to nobody. This can be undone.
- Withhold a name or an affiliation while a request is assessed: the name shows as "Name withheld", the affiliation is left out, and the PDF is not offered meanwhile. This can be undone.
- Correct the public details: a misspelt name, a wrong affiliation or ORCID identifier, or a typo in the title. The page, the citation and the metadata show the corrected detail with "Corrected on" and the date; the journal's own record of the paper as published keeps the original, and the published PDF is not changed. A correction can be undone.
- Delete a name or an affiliation because the law requires it. It is erased from the stored record of the paper (where the name becomes "Name withheld"), the submission record, the page, the citation, the metadata, profiles and lists. The old PDF is deleted at once: a paper written in the Platform's editor gets a new PDF with "Name withheld" within minutes; a paper published as an uploaded PDF has no PDF until staff upload a corrected one that passes our upload checks. This deletion is final: it cannot be undone, and it is applied again after any restore from a backup. The private editorial files of the paper (the authors' manuscript, its earlier versions and the PDFs of the review rounds, seen only by the authors and the editors) still contain the name: they are kept as the journal's editorial record.
Copies that others have already downloaded or archived are outside our control (Privacy Policy, Section 8).
10. Fees
- What the fees are. Submitting a paper carries a submission fee, and an accepted paper carries a publication fee. The prices, in tenge and US dollars, are on the Fees page and are shown before you pay.
- Promo codes. A promo code can lower the fee of your first submission, as the submission form shows when you apply it.
- When the fees are paid. The submission fee when you submit. The publication fee after the paper is accepted and the Author Agreement is signed, by card on the Platform (or by bank transfer where the editors offer it). The paper is published once the fee is paid or waived.
- Who pays. Every author acknowledges this notice when submitting. For a minor, a parent acknowledges it and is the only one who can be asked to pay.
- Fee waivers. An author who cannot pay can apply for a waiver of the submission fee, the publication fee or both, with the application form linked from the Fees page and the payment page. An author under 18 may apply themselves; the parent is notified. The editors decide and give the reason if they decline. A waiver can be withdrawn if the application turns out not to be true; the fee is then due.
- Payment never affects editorial decisions. An unpaid submission fee only holds the paper before screening, and an unpaid publication fee only delays publication. Neither ever changes an acceptance into a rejection, a waiver application never affects the editorial decision, and withdrawal is always free.
- Full terms for any payment are in the Terms of Sale, accepted separately before paying.
11. Open access, licence and archiving
All papers are open access under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY 4.0). Authors keep copyright. Papers carry stable URLs and citation metadata for Google Scholar from the first edition; digital object identifiers (DOIs) and an ISSN are added as soon as the journal's registrations are complete.
12. Editorial board and independence
The editor-in-chief is the operator of the Platform. We are forming an editorial board of academics from universities in Kazakhstan and abroad; their names will be published on the journal page once they have agreed. Section editors will be added as the journal grows. Editorial decisions are independent of sponsors, schools and promo-code partners.
13. Contact
Editorial questions, appeals and ethics concerns: [email protected].
14. Language
This document is published in Kazakh, Russian and English. The Kazakh and Russian texts have equal force. The English text is a translation for convenience; where it differs, the Kazakh and Russian texts apply.